Post Edit Home Help

Key Pages

Home |
Entries |
Categories |
Help |
- |
RSS

Changes [Feb 08, 2008]

Home
preliminary menu
pnyx hill
gortyn law code, cr...
ostracism
Tholos, Athens
Entries
   More Changes...
Changes [Feb 08, 2008]: Home, preliminary menu, pnyx hill, gortyn law code, cr..., ... MORE

Find Pages

This is not so much a coherent theory as a general reaction and move away from positivism. Postpositivism emerged amongst a group of thinkers in the philosophy of science, such as Kuhn and Feyerabend, and in analytic philosophy, or the philosophy of language, such as with Quine, Putnam and Rorty. More generally, the term is also applied to alternative approaches such as hermeneutics. A heterogenous group, all, to differing degrees, criticise the empiricist basis of positivism. In particular, positivism of the Vienna School, and to a lesser extent, the 'positivism' of Karl Popper, held several key tenets as part of its orienting methodology and epistemology. Among these, the post-positivists most severly questioned 1) the cumulative growth of scientific knowledge, or the 'cumulative convergence on truth' which justifies belief in a scientific realism (Kuhn and Feyerabend); and 2) a correspondence theory of such knowledge, in that such aggrandizing truths of science really do pertain to phenomena as they are in the world (Lakatos, Goodman, Putnam, Rorty, ~Quine) - ie. a justification of knowledge because it grants direct access to the real.

Postprocessual archaeology can certainly, though only partly, be associated with postpositivist philosophy because of its constitution as a reaction against the positivist bias of much processual archaeology. The postpositivist strain in postprocessual archaeology is a reinstatement of the social foundations and responsibilities of archaeological inquiry, a refusal to separate archaeological ‘science’ from discourse, and a suspicion of the value of unrestrained application of quantitative techniques.

References


Feyerabend, P. 1977: Against Method, London.
Kuhn, T.S. 1969: The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Chicago.
Putnam, H. 1979: Mind, Language, and Reality: philosophical papers, vol.2, Cambridge.
Quine, V.W. 1953: From a Logical Point of View, Cambridge, MA.

Edit this Page - Attach File - Add Image - References - Print
Page last modified by Tim Webmoor Mon Jan 22/2007 13:23
You must signin to post comments.
Site Home > Archaeopaedia > postpositivism